Guide
$250K to $500K across several accounts: how to consolidate, and how to compare fees in dollars

With $250,000 to $500,000 saved, the money is often spread out. There may be a 401(k) from each past job, an IRA or two, and a bank or brokerage account. So the questions change. What do you have, and where? What should happen to each old workplace plan? Who inherits each account? And if someone offers to manage it all, what will that cost in dollars?
This guide covers four jobs, using official sources: list your accounts on one page, decide what to do with each old plan, line up your beneficiary forms, and compare fees in dollars.
What the figure means. Here, "$250K to $500K" means investable assets: money in savings and investment accounts. That includes bank savings, brokerage accounts, IRAs and workplace plans such as a 401(k). It does not include your home's value, your income or your net worth.
What it does not mean. This band is Valora's way to group what tends to get more complex. It is not a legal or industry definition, and not a Valora eligibility rule. It is also not a sign that you should, or should not, hire help. Many people do this work themselves. Others pay for one piece of it.
This guide is for US readers. It is educational, not individual investment, tax or legal advice. Valora is not arranging advisor matches or introductions at this time. Check each linked official page before you act.
In short:
- Make a one-page list of every account, its tax type, where it is held and who inherits it.
- An old 401(k) has four usual choices: leave it, move it to a new plan, roll it to an IRA, or cash it out.
- Prefer a direct rollover. If a plan pays you instead, it generally withholds 20%, and you have 60 days to finish.
- Ask how the person suggesting a rollover gets paid. It can pay them more than leaving the money where it is.
- Check the beneficiary on every account. These forms typically override your will.
- Turn every fee into dollars a year for the same accounts and the same work.
Start with a one-page household inventory
Before you move any money, write down what you have. When you weigh combining old plans, the IRS suggests asking whether one plan would leave you "fewer accounts to track" (IRS: Termination of employment).
Make one row per account, for you and any spouse or partner:
| Column | What to write |
|---|---|
| Account | A nickname, such as "Old 401(k), first job" or "Rollover IRA." |
| Owner | Whose name is on it. |
| Tax type | Pre-tax (traditional), Roth, or taxable (a regular bank or brokerage account). |
| Held at | The plan or firm that holds it. |
| Rough value | A round number and the statement date. |
| Beneficiary on file | Primary and backup names, as the firm has them, and the date you checked. |
| Fees you can see | Plan fees, fund costs, any advisory fee. Blank is fine for now. |
Do not put account numbers, passwords or Social Security numbers on this sheet. And keep the tax type column accurate. Pre-tax and Roth money follow different rollover rules.
The fee column is often the hardest. For a workplace plan, the Department of Labor (DOL) says the plan should give you fee and investment information before you first choose investments, and every year after. You also get a quarterly statement of fees charged to your account. It does not show costs taken inside the funds (DOL: A look at 401(k) plan fees, September 2019).
An old 401(k): your four usual choices
When you leave a job, the IRS says you generally have four options for a workplace account such as a 401(k). Pensions work differently. FINRA and the SEC's Investor.gov list the same four (IRS; FINRA; Investor.gov). You can also split one account across more than one choice (FINRA Regulatory Notice 13-45).
A rollover, in plain words, moves retirement money from one plan or IRA to another without tax at that point. You generally pay tax only when you later take the money out (IRS: Rollovers).
1. Leave it in the old plan. The IRS says this can make sense if you like the plan's investments or its fees are low. It also works if you plan to move the money later. A small balance may not be allowed to stay. The IRS says the plan may then move it to an IRA in your name, or pay it out, if you do not choose (IRS: Rollovers).
2. Move it to your new employer's plan. The IRS says a plan does not have to accept rollovers, so ask first. Compare the two plans' investments and fees, and ask whether one account would be easier to track.
3. Roll it to an IRA. An IRA (individual retirement arrangement) is a tax-favored account you open yourself. The IRS notes that most IRAs offer a wide range of low-cost investments, and one IRA can gather several old plans. You can roll into a traditional or a Roth IRA. Pre-tax money rolled into a Roth IRA counts as income that year.
4. Cash it out. The IRS says you will likely pay income tax on any untaxed amount. You may also owe an extra 10% tax on early distributions. The IRS says this can apply if you aren't at least 55 (59½ for SEP and SIMPLE IRA plans). Other exceptions exist (IRS Topic 558). FINRA calls cashing out "costly, potentially involving significant taxes and early withdrawal penalties."
How the money moves: direct rollover or the 60-day rule
Direct rollover. The old plan pays the new plan or IRA directly. The IRS says no tax is withheld, even if the check is mailed to you made out to the new account. Between two IRAs, this is called a trustee-to-trustee transfer. IRS Publication 590-A says the direct option "will generally be to your advantage." You avoid the 20% withholding and the 10% additional tax (IRS Pub. 590-A).
The 60-day rule. If the plan pays the money to you, you have 60 days from the day you get it to deposit it in another plan or IRA. If you miss that, the amount is generally taxable (IRS Topic 413).
The 20% catch. A workplace plan must generally withhold 20% from a payout made to you, even if you plan to roll it over. To roll over the full amount, you make up that 20% from other money. The IRS example: Jordan, 42, takes a $10,000 payout and $2,000 is withheld. If she rolls over only $8,000, the $2,000 is taxable and may face the 10% additional tax. If she adds $2,000 of her own and rolls over $10,000, the whole payout stays tax-free (IRS: Rollovers).
Missed the 60 days? The IRS may waive the deadline if you missed it for reasons beyond your control. There are three routes. One is an automatic waiver, for example after a bank error. Another is a self-certification letter, with no IRS fee. The third is a private letter ruling, which has an IRS user fee (IRS: 60-day waiver FAQs).
One IRA-to-IRA rollover a year. You can make only one 60-day rollover between IRAs in any 12-month period, across all your IRAs. The limit does not apply to trustee-to-trustee transfers or to rollovers to or from a workplace plan (IRS: Rollovers).
What can go where. The IRS rollover chart shows which accounts can take which money. For example:
- A Roth IRA can roll only to another Roth IRA.
- Roth money in a 401(k), 403(b) or 457(b) can go to a Roth IRA or another Roth plan account.
- Pre-tax plan money can go to a traditional IRA or another pre-tax plan. If it goes to a Roth IRA, it counts as income.
Some payments cannot be rolled over at all, such as hardship distributions and required minimum distributions (IRS Topic 413). Before a payout, the old plan must give you a written explanation of your rollover options (Pub. 590-A). A rollover is not taxed, but it is still reported on your federal return (IRS Topic 413).

Questions to ask before you roll over
FINRA, the regulator for brokerage firms, set out the factors that matter when someone recommends rolling a plan into an IRA (FINRA Regulatory Notice 13-45, December 2013). It was written for firms, and some ages in it are out of date. But its questions make a good checklist:
- Investments. An IRA often offers more choices. If you like your plan's low-cost funds, that may matter less.
- Fees. Plans and IRAs both have investment costs and account fees. In some plans, the employer pays part of the admin costs.
- Services. Some plans offer advice, tools and help lines. IRA providers vary.
- Early access. FINRA says that if you leave a job between 55 and 59½, you may be able to take penalty-free withdrawals from the plan. From an IRA, that generally waits until 59½.
- Creditors. FINRA says plan assets generally have strong federal protection, while IRA protection depends more on bankruptcy and state law. Ask an attorney if this matters to you.
- Employer stock. Rolling company stock that has grown a lot into an IRA can have tax downsides, FINRA says. Ask a tax professional first.
The pay question. This one matters most. FINRA notes that a professional who recommends an IRA rollover "may earn commissions or other fees as a result." Leaving the money in the old plan, or moving it to a new employer's plan, "likely results in little or no compensation" for them. FINRA says an investment adviser who would earn an asset-based fee on the IRA has the same incentive. That does not make the advice wrong. Ask how the person is paid under each choice, and get it in writing.
Watch for "no fee" claims. The SEC is plain about it: "Investing isn't free" (Investor.gov). Read the new account's fee schedule and each fund's expense ratio, its yearly cost as a percentage of what you hold.
Beneficiary forms: check every account, not just the will
A beneficiary designation is the form that names who gets an account when you die.
They typically override your will. FINRA says retirement accounts "pass directly to named beneficiaries." Those designations "typically override instructions in your will and remain valid even through major life changes" (FINRA: Retirement accounts). A transfer-on-death (TOD) form on a brokerage account works the same way. FINRA says it "supersedes a will or trust" (FINRA, January 17, 2023).
Workplace plans may require your spouse. FINRA says your spouse is typically required to be your primary beneficiary in an employer plan, unless they sign a waiver. IRAs generally give you more choice. The IRS adds that you name a beneficiary under each plan's own procedures (IRS: Beneficiary).
Name a backup. FINRA notes you can typically name contingent (backup) beneficiaries. They inherit if your first choice dies before you, cannot be found or declines (FINRA: Advance planning, August 2025).
Recheck after every move. When you move an account to another firm, FINRA says to "double-check with the firm to be sure that any beneficiary designations also transfer." A new rollover IRA needs its own form. Fill it in when you open the account.
A simple routine:
- Ask each firm or plan who it has on record. Write the names and the date in your inventory.
- Compare them with your will, if you have one, and update any form that is out of date. FINRA says designations typically remain valid even through major life changes, so a regular review matters.
- Repeat whenever you open, close or move an account.
What heirs must do after inheriting a retirement account follows separate IRS rules, explained on the IRS beneficiary page.

Comparing a percentage fee to a flat fee, in dollars
Once your accounts are in one picture, someone may offer to manage all of it. Fees then come in two common shapes. One is a yearly percentage of the assets managed, often called an AUM fee (assets under management). The other is a flat dollar fee for a set scope of work. You can only compare them in dollars.
Why the percentage matters. The SEC says that if a fee is quoted as a percentage, you should understand what it means in dollars (Investor.gov). Two official examples show how small gaps add up:
- DOL. A worker has $25,000 in a 401(k), 35 years to go, 7% average returns and no new deposits. With 0.5% in fees and expenses, the account grows to $227,000. With 1.5%, it grows to only $163,000. The DOL says that 1-point gap cuts the final balance by 28%.
- SEC. A $100,000 investment grows 4% a year for 20 years. With a 0.50% yearly fee, it ends near $198,000. With 1.00%, it ends near $179,000 (Investor.gov, July 23, 2025).
These are official illustrations, not forecasts or typical fees. Do the same math on your own numbers:
- Pick the accounts the fee would cover. Ask the firm which accounts it would manage and bill on. An old 401(k) left in its plan may not be included, but it still has plan costs.
- Percentage fee: add those balances and multiply by the yearly rate. On the SEC's $100,000 example, 1% is about $1,000 in the first year. The dollar cost rises as the balance grows.
- Flat fee: write down the yearly dollar amount and what it covers.
- Add the costs on top. Either way, you may still pay fund costs, plan fees, custody or trading costs. The SEC notes retirement plan fees come "in addition to" the costs of the funds inside the plan.
- Compare the same work. Line up dollar totals only for the same scope: investing, planning, tax coordination, or all three.
Valora's investment future value calculator does not include fees. For a rough view, run it twice: once with your assumed return, and once with that return minus the quoted fee.
Where to find a firm's fees. An adviser's Form ADV Part 2A is its brochure, a plain-language disclosure filed with regulators. SEC instructions say Item 5 must give the fee schedule and say whether fees are negotiable. Item 5 must also say how fees are billed and what other costs you may pay (SEC: Form ADV Part 2 instructions). Some firms set account minimums, which Item 7 must disclose.
Cheaper is not the whole answer. The DOL says "cheaper is not necessarily better." Compare the services you get with the total cost.
Valora's fee-only vs commission-based guide explains pay labels. Our managing investments guide compares advisor scope and costs.

Before anyone helps with the move, check them
Check any professional before you share statements or sign transfer forms. Search the person and firm on Investor.gov, which links to the SEC's adviser search and FINRA's BrokerCheck. Ask for the firm's Form CRS, a short summary of services, fees, conflicts and disciplinary history. Ask if the person acts as a fiduciary, someone legally bound to put your interest first. The SEC says an investment adviser is a fiduciary under federal law (SEC Release IA-5248). Brokers must act in your best interest when they make a recommendation (Investor.gov: Brokers).
For the full walkthrough, see Valora's when to hire a financial advisor guide and first meeting checklist. For help with just this project, see one-time planning vs ongoing advice.
Want help applying this to your own accounts?
Tell us what you are trying to figure out. We'll review your request and email next steps. We aren't arranging advisor matches or introductions at this time. Please do not send account numbers, statements or tax documents through the form.
Putting it together: an order of work
- List every account on one page, without account numbers.
- Check names on every beneficiary form.
- Decide each old plan, after comparing fees, investments, services and early access.
- Move directly. If a check comes to you, mark the 60-day deadline.
- Recheck beneficiaries on any new account.
- Price help in dollars, for the same scope.
What this guide leaves to other pages. Choosing investments: our managing investments guide. Moving from work to retirement: our retirement planning guide. Yearly tax timing: our tax planning guide. Wills and trusts belong with an estate attorney.
Common questions
Is $250,000 or $500,000 a cutoff for hiring a financial advisor?
No. The band groups topics. It is not a rule. Some firms set account minimums, and Item 7 of their Form ADV brochure must disclose them. Others charge flat or hourly fees.
Does "$250K to $500K" include my home?
No. We mean savings and investment accounts: bank savings, brokerage accounts, IRAs and workplace plans.
Should I roll my old 401(k) into an IRA?
It depends on the plan. Compare fees, investments, services, early access and creditor protection. If you move it, the IRS says a direct rollover avoids the 20% withholding.
What if I miss the 60-day rollover deadline?
The amount is generally taxable, and the 10% additional tax may apply under 59½. The IRS may waive the deadline in some cases, such as a bank error.
Does my will decide who gets my 401(k) and IRAs?
Usually not. FINRA says beneficiary designations typically override a will. Check each account, and recheck after any move.
Sources
Internal Revenue Service: Rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions; Rollover chart (PDF); Topic no. 413, Rollovers from retirement plans; Publication 590-A (for 2025 returns); Retirement topics: Termination of employment; FAQs: Waivers of the 60-day rollover requirement; Topic no. 558, Additional tax on early distributions; Retirement topics: Beneficiary.
FINRA: Retirement accounts; Regulatory Notice 13-45, Rollovers to individual retirement accounts (December 30, 2013); Plan now to smooth the transfer of your brokerage account assets on death (January 17, 2023); Advance planning for your investments (August 2025, PDF).
U.S. Department of Labor, Employee Benefits Security Administration: A look at 401(k) plan fees (September 2019, PDF).
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and Investor.gov: How fees and expenses affect your investment portfolio (July 23, 2025); Switching jobs; Working with an investment professional; Check out your investment professional; Investor.gov/CRS; Brokers; Form ADV Part 2 instructions; Commission interpretation regarding standard of conduct for investment advisers (Release IA-5248, 2019).
Valora (related guides): Fee-only vs commission-based; Managing investments; When to hire a financial advisor; First meeting checklist; One-time planning vs ongoing advice; Retirement planning; Tax planning; Investment future value calculator.
Educational only. Not personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Valora is not a registered investment adviser and does not arrange advisor matches or introductions at this time. Government and regulator tools are named as ways to verify, not as endorsements of any firm.