Guide
Choosing a financial advisor for executive pay: what to check before you hire

To tell whether an advisor can handle executive pay, ask for evidence you can check, not claims. That means a registration you can look up, and a Form CRS and Form ADV brochure you have read. It also means a written scope that says who does the tax, plan, and legal work, and plain answers about how the firm is paid. Then decide whether a CPA or an attorney also belongs on the team.
This guide is for executives and senior professionals whose pay includes company stock, bonuses, or deferred pay, and who are about to choose help. It is about how to evaluate that help. If you want to understand the pay itself first, start with Valora's financial advisor for executives and professionals page. That page covers what you own, when you can sell, and how fees work when most of your wealth is company stock. For the details of each type of stock award, see financial advisor for tech employees.
This page is educational. It is not investment, tax, or legal advice. Valora is not arranging advisor matches or introductions at this time.
Key takeaways
- A title is not a license. "Executive financial advisor" or "equity compensation specialist" is a marketing phrase. Check the person's registration on Investor.gov and, for brokers, on FINRA BrokerCheck.
- Read two documents before the first real meeting. Form CRS is a short summary of services, fees, conflicts, and disciplinary history. The Form ADV Part 2 brochure is the longer version for advisers. Both are public.
- Test skill with questions about your own papers. An advisor who can handle executive pay asks for your plan documents and your company's trading rules before giving an opinion on selling.
- Get scope in writing. The written agreement should say what the advisor does, what they only coordinate, and what belongs to your CPA, your attorney, or your company.
- Bring in a CPA when tax is the question, and an attorney when a contract or legal status is the question. A good advisor will say so.
What this guide covers
This guide answers three questions. How can you tell whether an advisor can handle executive pay? What should you verify before you hire them? When should a CPA or an attorney join the team? It does not explain how stock awards work or how to plan around them. Valora's profession page for executives covers that.
Signs an advisor can handle executive pay
Most advisors can talk about stock awards. Fewer can work inside the rules that come with them. Here is what to look for, and what each sign tells you.
They ask for your documents before they give an opinion. Executive pay runs on paper: award agreements, the stock plan, any deferred pay plan, your offer letter, and your company's insider trading policy. An advisor who tells you to sell or keep shares before reading those papers is guessing.
They ask whether you are an insider. Many companies limit when certain employees can trade. A capable advisor asks about trading windows and pre-clearance (your company's approval before you trade) early. They also know these answers come from your company's legal or compliance team, not from them.
They use plain words and still get the terms right. Ask them to explain the awards you hold in two sentences each. You might hold restricted stock units (RSUs: shares you receive when they vest), employee stock purchase plan shares (ESPP: a plan that lets you buy company stock through payroll), or stock options. Options come as incentive stock options (ISOs) or nonstatutory stock options (NSOs), and the IRS treats them differently (IRS Topic No. 427). If the explanation is vague, or wrong about which type you have, that tells you something.
They know where their job ends. Ask, "What will you not do for me?" A strong answer names tax return work, legal review of agreements, and your company's trading decisions as outside their role. A weak answer is "we handle everything."
They can show you what the work produces. Ask for a sample of the written output with client details removed. That might be a sell schedule, a tax reserve plan made with a CPA, or a memo on a deferral election. A firm that cannot describe a concrete deliverable may not have done this work before.
They talk about tax without promising results. The IRS says that with an employer stock option you may have income when you receive it, when you exercise it, or when you sell it, depending on the type (Topic No. 427). An advisor should know these moments exist. Exact numbers for your year belong with a tax professional.
They do not want inside information. Material nonpublic information (MNPI) is information that is not yet public and that a reasonable investor would consider important when deciding whether to trade. The SEC describes illegal insider trading as trading on that kind of information, and says it can also include "tipping" it to someone else (Investor.gov: Insider trading). A good advisor never asks for it and stops you if you start to share it.

Titles and letters are not licenses
Many advisors list letters after their names. Some take serious study. Others take very little. FINRA keeps a professional designations database where you can look up a set of letters. It shows what training the issuer requires, whether there is continuing education, and whether you can confirm who holds the credential. FINRA states that it does not approve or endorse any credential or designation.
A designation is a training claim. A registration is a legal status. They answer different questions, so check both:
- Designation: look it up in FINRA's database. Then confirm with the issuer that this person holds it.
- Registration: look up the person and the firm on Investor.gov. The SEC says the most important question before hiring an investment professional is whether they are registered with the SEC or a state securities regulator (Investor.gov: Working with an investment professional).
"Executive advisor" is not a registration category you can look up. The registrations that are look-ups are investment adviser (SEC or state) and broker-dealer. If someone uses a phrase like that, ask what training or registration stands behind it.
What to verify, in order
Do these checks before you share any personal financial details. They take an evening, and they are free.
1. Confirm registration
Type the person's name into the search on Investor.gov. It sends you to the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site (IAPD). There you can see whether the person and the firm are registered with the SEC, a state, or FINRA, and whether there is any disciplinary history. For brokers, it may send you on to FINRA BrokerCheck.
2. Learn whether you are dealing with a broker, an adviser, or both
The SEC describes two kinds of firms (Investor.gov/CRS). A broker-dealer (broker) typically carries out trades and recommends specific investments, and is often paid per trade. An investment adviser typically gives ongoing advice and monitoring, and is often paid an ongoing fee based on the value of your account. Many firms are both. The SEC calls them dual registrants, and says you should understand when the person is acting as a broker and when as an adviser.
3. Read the Form CRS
Brokers and advisers must give retail investors a relationship summary, called Form CRS (Investor.gov/CRS). It tells you:
- what services the firm offers
- what fees and costs you will pay
- what conflicts of interest the firm may have
- the standard of conduct that applies
- whether the firm and its people have reportable legal or disciplinary history
- key questions to ask
Each firm's summary uses similar headings in the same order, so you can lay two side by side.
4. Read the Form ADV Part 2 brochure (advisers)
Form ADV is the form advisers use to register with the SEC and the states. Part 2 is a brochure in plain English about the adviser's business, fees, conflicts of interest, and disciplinary information. The SEC calls it the primary disclosure document for advisers (Investor.gov: Form ADV). Both parts are public on IAPD.
As you read, look for three things that matter for executive pay. How does the firm charge? Does it earn money from products or loans it might recommend? Does it describe any special work with stock plans, or only general investing?
5. Ask what "fiduciary" means for your account
A fiduciary is someone with a legal duty to put your interests first. For investment advisers, the SEC says this duty includes a duty of care and a duty of loyalty, and that the adviser cannot place its own interests ahead of yours (SEC interpretation, 2019). The duty follows the scope of the relationship you agree with the adviser. The federal fiduciary duty itself may not be waived. So ask: "Are you acting as a fiduciary for all of the advice you give me, including advice about my company stock? Will you put that in writing?" Then check that the answer matches the standard of conduct in the Form CRS.
6. Ask for fees in dollars
The SEC's advice is simple. If a fee is quoted as a percentage, make sure you understand what that means in dollars (Investor.gov: Working with an investment professional). Executive pay adds questions about what the fee is charged on. Valora's profession page walks through them, and our fee-only vs commission-based guide explains the labels.
Have a question about your next step?
Tell us what you are trying to figure out. We'll review your request and email next steps. We aren't arranging advisor matches or introductions at this time.
Get the scope in writing
When stock awards are a big part of your pay, several people touch the same decision. Problems tend to start where one person's job ends and the next begins. A written scope closes those gaps.
Before you sign an advisory agreement, check that it, or a letter that goes with it, answers these questions:
- Services. What exactly will the advisor do? Planning only, managing accounts, or both?
- Company stock held elsewhere. Will they give advice on shares and awards held at your company's plan provider, even if they do not manage those accounts?
- Trading rules. How will they work within your company's trading windows and pre-clearance rules?
- Trading plans. If you are an officer or director, will they help you decide what a Rule 10b5-1 plan should do? (A 10b5-1 plan is a trading plan set up in advance under an SEC rule. The SEC amended the rule in 2022 and added new conditions and disclosures (SEC final rule). Whether you can use one is a question for your company's counsel and your broker.)
- Tax work. Will they work with your CPA, and how? Who prepares projections? Who files returns?
- Legal work. Which questions will they send to an attorney?
- What you get. What written work will you receive, and how often?
- Fees. What is the fee in dollars for the first year, and what is it charged on?
- Ending the agreement. How do you end it, and what does it cost to leave?

When a CPA belongs on the team
Bring in a tax professional when the question is about what you owe, when you owe it, or how to report it. With executive pay, that comes up often. The IRS notes that stock options can create income at different moments depending on the type, and that exercising an ISO may bring alternative minimum tax in that year (Topic No. 427). The details for your year belong with someone who prepares returns.
Common signs you need a CPA, not only an advisor:
- you are deciding when to exercise options or sell shares, and want to know the tax result first
- a large vest or bonus is coming, and you are not sure the tax taken from your pay will cover the bill
- you have a deferred pay election due and want to understand the tax effect
- you received tax forms from your employer about stock you do not understand
How to check a tax professional. The IRS explains the main credentials (IRS: Understanding tax return preparer credentials). Anyone with a preparer tax identification number (PTIN) can prepare federal returns. Certified public accountants (CPAs) are licensed by state boards of accountancy. Enrolled agents (EAs) are licensed by the IRS. CPAs, enrolled agents, and attorneys have unlimited rights to represent clients before the IRS, including in audits and appeals. You can check a CPA license through your state board or the national lookup at CPAverify.
Ask the CPA the same scope questions. Will they run projections before a sale or exercise, or only prepare the return afterward? Will they talk directly with your advisor? Valora's tax planning guide covers this kind of help more broadly.
When an attorney belongs on the team
Bring in an attorney when the question is about what a contract means, what your rights are, or what you are legally allowed to do. An advisor can tell you how a choice fits your plan. They should not interpret a contract for you.
Common signs you need your own attorney:
- you are reviewing an offer letter, employment agreement, severance package, or change-in-control agreement
- a job change may cost you awards that have not vested yet, and you want to know your options under the agreement
- you are setting up or updating a will, trust, or other estate documents
- you are unsure whether a trade or a disclosure rule applies to you personally
Company counsel and your own attorney are different. Your company's legal and compliance team owns questions about insider status, trading windows, pre-clearance, and approval of trading plans. They work for the company. If your own interests may differ from the company's, ask whether you need your own attorney as well. You can confirm that an attorney is licensed through your state's bar or court system (IRS credentials page notes that attorneys are licensed by state courts or their designees, such as the state bar).
Your company's plan administrator is not your advisor. The stock plan provider and your HR team keep grant records, vesting schedules, and plan rules. They can tell you what the plan says. They usually do not tell you what you should do.
Questions to ask, and what the answers tell you
Use these in a first call. The answer matters, but so does whether the person answers directly.
| Question | A stronger answer | A weaker answer |
|---|---|---|
| "What do you need to see before you give me an opinion on my company stock?" | Names award agreements, plan documents, recent statements, and your insider trading policy | Gives an opinion on the call |
| "What will you not do?" | Names tax filing, legal review, and company trading decisions | "We handle everything" |
| "Are you a fiduciary for all the advice you give me?" | A clear yes or no, in writing, that matches the Form CRS | Talks around the question |
| "How are you paid, and what conflicts do you have?" | Points you to the Form CRS and explains each conflict | "There are no conflicts" |
| "What would my first-year fee be in dollars?" | Gives a number or a clear range, and says what it is charged on | Gives only a percentage |
| "How do you work with my CPA?" | Describes who prepares projections and how often they talk | "We can do the tax side too," with no credential named |
| "What written work will I receive?" | Describes a deliverable and offers a sample with details removed | Cannot describe one |
Red flags specific to executive pay:
- pressure to sell or keep shares "right now" without reading your documents
- promises about how much tax you will save
- asking about unannounced company news
- pushing a loan backed by your shares before your plan is clear. FINRA notes that these securities-backed lines of credit can be a key revenue source for securities firms (FINRA: Securities-backed lines of credit). The risks include tax consequences, the possibility that you might have to sell your holdings, and larger losses when markets fall.
- refusing to put fees, conflicts, or scope in writing

A made-up example: comparing two advisors
This example is made up. The people and firms are not real.
Dana is a vice president at a public company. Dana holds RSUs and some vested options, and has a deferred pay election due in a few weeks. Dana interviews two firms.
The first advisor gives a firm view on selling Dana's shares during the first call. When asked about trading windows, the advisor says that is "a compliance thing." The fee is quoted only as a percentage. The firm says it can "take care of the tax side," but no one at the firm is a CPA or enrolled agent.
The second advisor asks for the award agreements, the deferred pay plan summary, and the company's trading policy before giving any view. The advisor says the deferral election needs a tax projection, and asks whether Dana already has a CPA. The advisor points Dana to the firm's Form CRS, explains two conflicts listed there, and gives a first-year fee in dollars. The written scope lists what the advisor will do, what the CPA will do, and that questions about Dana's severance terms go to an attorney.
The second firm is not right because it sounds more careful. It is a better fit because every claim it made can be checked: on IAPD, in the Form CRS, and in the written scope.
When you may not need an ongoing advisor
Not everyone with stock awards needs ongoing advice. If your question is narrow, such as one exercise decision or one deferral election, a CPA alone, or a one-time planning project, may be enough. The SEC notes that people who like to read and ask questions may not need investment advice, while busy people may want help (Investor.gov: Working with an investment professional). The checks on this page still apply to a one-time project.
Want to ask about your next step?
Share a few details about your situation and goals. We'll review your request and email next steps. We aren't arranging advisor matches or introductions at this time. Please do not send account numbers or company documents through the form.
The bottom line
Executive pay is complex, but choosing help for it is mostly about checking. Look up the registration. Read the Form CRS and the Form ADV brochure. Ask questions that need your own documents to answer. Get the scope, the fiduciary answer, and the fee in dollars in writing. Bring in a CPA for tax and an attorney for contracts. An advisor who welcomes those checks is more likely to be one you can rely on.
Common questions
Is "executive financial advisor" a license or credential?
No. "Executive financial advisor" is not a federal or state registration category, and it is not a license. Anyone can use that label. The registrations you can look up are investment adviser (with the SEC or a state) and broker-dealer, plus the people who work at those firms. Ask what registration is behind the title, then confirm it on Investor.gov or FINRA BrokerCheck.
What is the difference between Form CRS and Form ADV?
Form CRS is a short relationship summary that brokers and advisers give retail investors. It covers services, fees, conflicts, standard of conduct, and disciplinary history. Form ADV is the adviser registration form. Its Part 2 brochure gives a longer plain English account of the adviser's business, fees, conflicts, and disciplinary information. Both are public on IAPD.
Can my company's stock plan provider give me advice?
The plan provider and HR keep your grant records and explain the plan rules. They usually do not tell you what you should do. Personal advice comes from an advisor, a CPA, or an attorney you hire.
Do I need a CPA if I already have a financial advisor?
Often, yes, when the question is about tax. Stock options and other awards can create tax at different moments. A CPA or enrolled agent can run projections and prepare returns. Ask your advisor how they work with one.
Where can I learn how my stock awards work?
Start with Valora's financial advisor for executives and professionals and financial advisor for tech employees pages. For tax rules, see IRS Topic No. 427 and Publication 525, and ask a tax professional about your own year.
What should I send through the inquiry form?
Describe the question you want to ask. Do not send account numbers, tax returns, award agreements, or any unannounced company information.
Sources
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (Investor.gov): Investor.gov/CRS; Form ADV; Check out your investment professional; Working with an investment professional; Insider trading.
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission: Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers (2019); Insider Trading Arrangements and Related Disclosures (final rule, 2022); Investment Adviser Public Disclosure.
FINRA: BrokerCheck; Professional designations; Securities-backed lines of credit explained.
Internal Revenue Service: Topic No. 427, Stock options; Publication 525; Understanding tax return preparer credentials and qualifications.
NASBA: CPAverify (license lookup tool only).
Valora (related guides): Financial advisor for executives and professionals; Financial advisor for tech employees; Fee-only vs commission-based; Tax planning.
Educational only. Not personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Valora is not a registered investment adviser and does not arrange advisor matches or introductions at this time. Government and regulator tools are named as ways to verify, not as endorsements of any firm.